Heya Folks,
300 Alchemist here and I thought I'd try the new tradeskill trophy quest. I talked to the Event Coordinator in the newbie area of freeport west and got the quest. Showed her my old alchemy Trophy (GM Medicine Bag). Then following her instructions, I showed the trophy the the Judge. Now There is a Warning to this effect in the quest dialog...But YOU WILL NOT GET YOUR TROPHY (GM Medicine Bag) BACK AFTER YOU GIVE IT TO THE JUDGE. I got credit for completing that portion of the quest in my task window but I would rather have the bag! Hahahaha stoopid curious cat.
The bummer for me is now I have to do all this darn alchemy tradeskilling without my trophy mod or the clicky bag for holding junk. My advice is to do the entire quest and turn your Trophy in LAST.
Spatters Vah Shir