The Spirit Realm

which priates drop the rum for this task been killing pirates for a while still can't seem to get any drops, i assume the pirates on Jordals hook island but which ones lol /boggle

They can be very rare. they drop on first isle with quest givers.

The best way to find answers to that type of question is . Use the little search field in the left column. It's free.

In your case: http://eq.magelo.com/item/88245

The ones on the island with the big boat bar. Pull the mobs out of the bar. They seemed to drop them more. I did this for two characters. Doing this i had a druid so was able to harmonize the mobs. Otherwise u get multiples.

Drop rate of all other mobs around the ship on outside was far worse.

Yes either from inside or fromt he upper deck after levi.