I'd be pretty surprised if a group geared for that zone could kill that at all, unless an enchanter is expected to be required for it. If it's not, it's overtuned. It's not like I'm walking around in bazaar gear here hehe
Since I was asked, I'm posting some more detailed info on it.
Hits for Geartop:
Rihard - vs - Geartop
Attempts 99
Missed 10
Dodged 12
Parried 15
Blocked 0
Riposted 5
396 1
545 2
546 1
571 1
623 1
650 10
681 1
692 7
711 1
830 3
840 1
922 5
1008 2
1137 1
1515 1
1541 1
1712 1
1897 1
1909 1
2025 3
2074 1
2172 1
2321 1
2607 1
2699 1
2765 1
3489 2
3505 1
4278 1
4673 2
Hits for Geartop + Tinytops:
Rihard - vs - Combined: A tinytop
Attempts 1124
Missed 241
Dodged 137
Parried 146
Blocked 58
Riposted 67
23 2
30 6
85 1
111 1
113 1
194 1
211 2
256 5
257 1
275 1
281 1
318 27
341 13
342 2
344 1
349 1
351 1
356 1
362 1
365 1
373 1
380 1
382 4
396 1
424 107
444 3
457 1
507 16
532 1
545 2
546 1
570 1
571 1
591 8
608 2
616 2
623 1
632 2
650 15
675 11
681 1
684 2
687 1
692 7
695 7
711 1
758 4
759 10
820 2
830 3
840 1
842 15
883 2
922 5
926 4
984 1
1008 6
1010 9
1060 2
1093 12
1114 1
1134 2
1137 1
1154 1
1177 5
1197 1
1210 1
1260 1
1261 18
1323 1
1344 14
1386 1
1428 19
1454 1
1511 1
1512 9
1515 1
1541 1
1596 10
1679 6
1712 1
1763 5
1847 3
1897 1
1909 1
1930 3
2014 5
2025 3
2074 1
2172 1
2321 1
2607 1
2699 1
2765 1
3489 2
3505 1
4278 1
4673 2
AC buffed at the time was somewhere in the 4600-4700 range, HP around 32k.
Magelos for toons used:
http://eq.magelo.com/profile/635986
http://eq.magelo.com/profile/1368164
http://eq.magelo.com/profile/1274943
http://eq.magelo.com/profile/1187970
http://eq.magelo.com/profile/1321192
Cleric doesn't have an up to date magelo, but around 16200 mana unbuffed, 400 mana clicky, 30% spell haste to 70, 45% improved healing to 80, bit over 2400 AA.
Like I said before, an enchanter completely trivializes this fight. Without an enchanter though, you better be packing better than group gear.